Articles About Internews

Kremlin accused on media freedoms
May 2, 2007
By Steven Eke, BBC Russia analyst
Journalists will mark World Press Freedom Day on 3 May amid
growing concern about what campaigners say is a continuing global
decline in media freedoms.
Russia is again singled out, as a country whose government is allegedly
taking aggressive measures to curb media freedom.
In its recently published annual study, the US-based Freedom House
suggests that Vladimir Putin's policies have been a "template" for
repressive governments the world over.
It asserts that Russia's once "lively and probing" press, has been
turned into "a toothless sounding board" for official opinion.
The Russian government counters such accusations by pointing
to the thousands of non-state publications.
Generally, Russian officials react extremely badly to suggestions
that their country ranks alongside Burma, Cuba and North Korea,
for media freedom. They insist that there is a genuine pluralism
of opinion - in the printed media, at least.
However, television remains the predominant source of information
for the majority of Russians. And it does not allow opposition
voices to be heard.
Many Russia-watchers have followed the change of tone and
content of state television over recent years.
Shift to 'positive' news
Increasingly, hard-hitting investigative journalism has been replaced
by Soviet-style "razoblacheniya" - or exposes. They often look
crude and carry unsubstantiated allegations.
In addition, any form of satire aimed at the president or his
closest associates seems to be totally forbidden.
Equally, there is an obvious shift in favour of "positive" news,
presenting an optimistic picture of Russian life, especially
when compared to events in the neighbouring countries, which
are often portrayed as unstable.
The governments of some of those countries - especially Ukraine,
Georgia, and, most recently, Estonia - complain that Russian
state television sometimes broadcasts allegations that are simply
untrue, and which exacerbate xenophobic sentiments.
Two weeks ago, Russian police and the FSB (internal security
service) raided the offices of Educated Media Foundation (EMF),
the main partner of the California-based InterNews Network.
Investigators have brought criminal charges against the organisation's
director, Manana Aslamazyan, who had failed to declare 9,500
euros on a customs form.
Lawyers say she acknowledges her error, but insist that it should
in no way serve as a justification for the raid on, and subsequent
closure of, EMF.
Foreign cash
In an unprecedented response, nearly 2,000 Russian journalists,
including many household names, have signed an open letter deploring
the authorities' action as "another step infringing on the civil
rights enshrined in the Russian Constitution".
The letter called on President Putin to intervene personally,
to prevent the "destruction" of an organisation it described
as producing "the pride of Russian television".
There seems to be little realistic chance of that happening.
In his recent - and probably final - address to parliament, the
Russian leader warned of "ever-increasing flows of cash from
abroad", allegedly being used to finance opposition groups.
Media freedom groups warn that the Russian government may soon
take measures to regulate the internet. Access is growing very
Last month, President Putin signed a decree establishing a new body
to supervise the mass media and internet content. Officials insist
it will be in charge of licensing, rather than regulating, what's available.
But Russia's parliament - which critics say rubber-stamps President
Putin's proposals - is considering ways of clamping down on "extremism" on
the internet.
And in Russia, the concept of "extremism" has been widened significantly,
beyond the initial intention of tackling violent racists and neo-Nazis.
Increasingly, the mainstream opposition finds itself branded "extremist".
Contract-style murders
Some of Russia's leading online journalists say the government
will not succeed in controlling the internet, if that is its
intention. They point to the failure of similar measures abroad,
especially in China and Turkey.
To be fair, there are newspapers in Russia - Novaya Gazeta,
and Kommersant, among others - that carry considered, informed,
balanced writing. Their readerships are not large - perhaps in
the tens of thousands.
But they do put Russia in a different league than North Korea
or Turkmenistan.
This said, Russian liberals warn that, in the current atmosphere,
critical journalists are increasingly likely to be targeted for
physical retribution.
Russia is acknowledged to be a dangerous place to be a journalist,
with very few of the contract-style murders of journalists in
recent years resulting in a conviction.
|