Articles About Internews

A Stunning Miscalculation
May 15, 2007
By Alexei Pankin
After observing Defense Minister Anatoly Serdyukov during the Victory
Day parade on Red Square, military affairs analyst Vitaly Shlykov had
the following to say: "Russian generals will be afraid of this guy.
But the president doesn't plan to use him to frighten anyone else. The
rest of the world has nothing to worry about."
Stalin's purges stripped the top brass of any desire to be an independent
political player. Yet when the infighting among the political elite
has become particularly intense, the position of the military has tipped
the scales. This was the case when Beria and Khrushchev were deposed,
as well as in August 1991 and October 1993.
We are now approaching another watershed moment. President Vladimir
Putin seems bent on going down in history as the first Russian ruler
to step down according to schedule. Putin and his inner circle must
understand, however, that the departure of the person who stands at
the pinnacle of the power vertical will inevitably lead to an escalation
of the feuds within the elite. And in a society with fledgling democratic
institutions, the consequences of such escalation are impossible to
predict.
The decision to put Serdyukov -- formerly head of the Federal Tax Service
and a close ally of Viktor Zubkov, head of the Federal Financial Monitoring
Service -- in charge of a military bureaucracy that suffers from all
the same vices as the civilian bureaucracy effectively eliminated the
military as a political force. Some might call this a Byzantine arrangement,
others -- civilian control of the armed forces.
Compared with this clever maneuver, however, some of the Kremlin's
other recent moves are difficult to fathom.
The first of these is the case of the Educated Media Foundation, the
legal successor of Internews, and its president, Manana Aslamazian.
Aslamazian was detained in late January at Sheremetyevo Airport for
failing to declare less than $3,000 in cash in excess of the $10,000
legal limit. Then last month, the foreign-funded nongovernmental organization
was shut down temporarily after police raided its Moscow office and
confiscated computers and documents.
The paradox is that Putin and Aslamazian think alike on a number of
issues. Putin has said many times that the economic independence of
media companies and sound management practices are the cornerstone of
an independent press. The Educated Media Foundation was teaching sound
management techniques to regional television stations.
Putin talks about the dictatorship of the law. The Educated Media Foundation
conducted large-scale projects that helped regional media to bring their
activities into line with current laws.
Given this coincidence of goals, it would make much more sense for
the Kremlin to give the Educated Media Foundation its blessing and let
it get on with its good work rather than the heavy-handed approach it
has taken.
At present, the regime's top priority is to ensure a smooth succession
when Putin steps down next March. With this in mind, the Kremlin's biggest
mistake was to underestimate Aslamazian's charisma. She is passionately
devoted to her work, exceptionally unselfish and very kind. Her students,
who work in many Moscow and regional television stations, hold her in
the highest regard.
By subjecting Aslamazian to persecution that exceeds all reasonable
limits, the government has personally offended thousands of journalists
and media managers. And a shared personal affront can bind people even
more tightly than shared beliefs and interests. Among the more than
2,000 people who recently signed an open letter to Putin in support
of Aslamazian there are quite a few who would be unlikely to join forces
in any other cause.
I find it impossible to comprehend how the same leaders who neatly
neutralized the military could turn around and needlessly antagonize
the press, which in periods of transition can prove no less destructive
than the generals.
Alexei Pankin is the editor of Mediaprofi, a monthly magazine for
regional media professionals.
|